Depends on your group
- Our take
- Reddit commenters in the Lords/Warriors thread were lukewarm: one used it 2-3 times and called it bloat, another said it adds many rules for mechanics they do not find compelling and makes games swingy, a third has not considered adding it, and one said their games with it were each decided by the last die roll. BGG still rates it about 8.3 with about 1.7K ratings and about 11K owners, so it is liked by many who own it.
- What you need first
- Just the base game