Spirit Island expansions
Jagged Earth vs Feather and Flame
Short answer: buy Jagged Earth first. Best value if you play often. Big and more complex, so many get it second.
Pick Feather and Flame first instead if this sounds more like your table: Can be added any time. Good if you want more Spirits but not more rules.
| Question | Jagged Earth | Feather and Flame |
|---|---|---|
| Our label | Worth it | Worth it |
| Buy order | #2 for Spirit Island | #3 for Spirit Island |
| What it adds | Ten new Spirits, more Adversaries, and parts for up to 6 players. A very big box. | Four Spirits, 5 Aspects, 5 Fear cards, 2 Scenarios and 1 Adversary. Collects Promo Packs 1 and 2. |
| What it fixes | Lets 5 or 6 people play and adds lots of Spirit variety. | Adds new Spirits without many new rules. |
| Type | Expansion | Expansion |
| Players | 1–6 players | — |
| Rules load | Adds more rules | About the same rules load |
| Best for | — | — |
| You need first | Just the base game | Just the base game |
| Price guide | $60–$100 | $20–$40 |
| More | Jagged Earth details | Feather and Flame details |