Depends on your group
- Our take
- BGG threads and Reddit split: some say it adds asymmetry and bag diversification, but more say it bloats a light game (more steps, higher scores, extra table space) and prefer Witches first. Meeple Mountain calls it largely empty calories next to Witches, while IGN lists both as non-essential; r/boardgames posters like it only for new Fortune Teller cards and asymmetry.
- What you need first
- Needs the base Quacks of Quedlinburg game; can be played with the base alone or combined with The Herb Witches. Does not add a fifth-player kit, so five players need The Herb Witches or All-In.